Back to all posts
The Downstream Distribution Problem: Why Your Content Disappears After Publication
•Erik Svilich, Founder & CEO | Encypher | C2PA Text Co-Chair

The Downstream Distribution Problem: Why Your Content Disappears After Publication

Your content reaches millions through syndication, aggregators, and AI training—but the connection to your organization vanishes. Here's why this matters and what's changing.

#ContentProvenance#Publishing#Copyright#AITraining#ContentProtection

By: Erik Svilich, Founder & CEO | Encypher | C2PA Text Co-Chair

"You can get all of AP's content without having to go to apnews.com." 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇁󠇒󠄄󠄃󠆼󠄈󠄻󠆐󠅼󠅮󠆍󠆜󠄾︃󠆓󠇌󠅮󠆠󠆹󠅍󠄩󠅸󠄿󠅍󠆅󠄨󠅕︀󠇩󠅳󠇙󠆡󠄋󠅄󠇝︃󠄧󠆵󠄝󠆇This observation from a senior executive at one of the world's largest news organizations captures a problem that's costing publishers billions: the downstream distribution problem. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇢󠆸󠇘󠆸󠇃󠆄󠄻󠇈󠅹󠆟󠆥󠄩󠅯󠄠󠆗󠅮󠆬󠆙󠆆󠇄󠅡󠇦󠅏󠄎󠄿󠇊󠇩󠅈󠅐󠆲󠄨󠄫󠄻󠆅︁︃󠆔󠅠󠅰󠅮When you publish content, it doesn't stay on your website. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄚󠆜󠆢󠆑󠄫󠆈󠄹󠄪󠆄󠇜󠄌󠆳󠄉󠇗󠅌󠇩󠆞󠄟󠅿󠆶󠅘󠇚󠇘󠆛󠆲󠅕󠄃︃󠅿󠇗󠅟󠄽󠄲︊󠄽︍󠆁󠄖󠄃󠇑It flows through a complex ecosystem of licensees, aggregators, social platforms, and now AI training pipelines. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄟󠆿︊󠅑󠆜󠄬󠄵󠄻󠅽󠇅󠄿︁󠅃󠄚󠇥󠅛󠇕󠄅󠅰󠅫󠅃󠅮󠄦󠅗󠄐󠄕󠆒︃︌︈󠄺󠆢󠄷󠄼󠅞󠄅󠆈󠇜󠄙󠇖And somewhere along that journey, the connection between your content and your organization disappears entirely.

The Content Distribution Ecosystem

Let's trace what happens to a single article after publication:

󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄠󠆗󠄄️󠆬󠅭󠄰󠅹󠆂󠅡󠇫︃󠆭󠅕󠅅󠄴󠇫︎󠇬󠅁󠄠󠆎󠆟󠅺󠅁󠅠󠅤󠇔󠅄︌󠆸󠄷󠅅󠄕󠆜󠇏󠇄󠅽󠅲󠄫The Traditional Path

  1. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇖󠇊󠆉󠆎󠇉󠇁󠄵󠅞󠆉󠄂󠅋󠅽󠄾󠆫󠄇󠄕󠆟󠅿󠆬󠇛󠆩󠅼󠄟󠇬󠄐󠇈󠅜󠆪󠅩󠅓󠆛󠄁󠇈󠇯󠅭󠆶️󠅄󠆷󠆍Original Publication — Article appears on publisher's website
  2. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆼󠄻󠄾︎󠇇󠄪󠄴󠇓󠆡︁󠆥󠆈󠇗󠅶󠄴󠆬󠅘󠅁︉󠇎󠅪󠄞󠅿󠅕󠆻󠅎󠅲️󠅑󠆥󠅦󠅟󠄒󠅲󠅊󠆏󠅩󠇐󠄿󠆯Wire Services — Syndicated to AP, Reuters, or other wire services
  3. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇔󠄁󠆿󠆙󠇞󠆤󠄲󠇡󠆝󠆋󠆹󠆮󠄧󠄁󠄕󠇊󠆘󠆗󠆠󠇇󠄅󠇉󠄃󠇩󠅐󠄪󠇫󠇞󠆫󠅼󠅚󠆈󠅟󠆱󠇬󠇌󠇆󠄱󠇞󠇁B2B Licensees — Licensed to other news organizations
  4. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆰󠄧󠄂󠄒󠅱󠆵󠄷󠅏󠆙󠆴󠆍󠆾󠇖󠅲󠆄󠇊󠆋󠅆󠆞󠄕󠅶󠆙󠄮󠅹󠆁󠇧󠆬󠅶󠄭󠇌󠆳󠆣󠇢󠇪󠅼󠆫︉󠆱󠆦󠇍Aggregators — Picked up by Google News, Apple News, Flipboard
  5. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅵󠄷󠆎󠅋󠆽󠆫󠄻󠆁󠆉︄󠆍️󠇙󠄆󠅳󠆓︋󠄛󠆉󠇈󠇒󠄛󠇩󠆌󠆘󠅳󠆰󠄬󠅛󠆥󠆚︅󠄑󠄞󠄍󠇦󠅴󠅙󠄳󠅊Social Sharing — Excerpts shared on Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook
  6. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄟󠅖󠅇󠆬︀󠇮󠄺︀󠆜󠅷󠅧󠇩󠄬󠄣︅󠇤󠅭󠇟󠆪󠄱󠄃󠇀󠅭󠄈󠆗󠆄󠅓️󠄊󠆿󠇈󠆲︆󠅃󠄨󠅀󠆄󠅞󠄵󠆀Archival Services — Indexed by Wayback Machine, news archives

󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢︂󠅤󠇄︈󠇨󠆌󠄷󠅑󠆠󠇥󠆠󠆔󠇛󠄵󠄮󠄤󠄥󠇃︇󠆅󠅰󠇏󠇑󠄿󠇜󠅝󠆧󠆺󠇜︅󠆵󠄁󠅟󠅘󠅽󠆏󠇄󠇓󠆅󠇞The New AI Path

Now add these destinations:

  1. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄟︅󠆌󠄦󠇉󠅕󠄻︆󠆖󠄆󠆉󠆆󠆗󠆬󠅨󠆕󠆇󠅧󠆃󠆍󠅢󠄏󠄮󠄴󠇘󠇈󠅟󠄧󠇫󠆴󠆉󠅤󠆄󠆙󠅊︈󠆙󠆖󠄷󠅜Web Scrapers — Collected by Common Crawl and similar projects
  2. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄑󠆿󠅬󠅣󠄰󠇠󠄲󠆨󠆦󠅑󠇈󠅽︍󠆈󠄓󠆫󠆕󠄯󠄡󠇇󠇫󠆲󠅡󠇩󠅚︋󠅋󠄰󠄠󠅜󠅟󠄺󠅌󠆮󠇯󠆋󠄫󠄤󠆽󠆞AI Training Datasets — Incorporated into training corpora
  3. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅞󠅓󠄠󠅉󠅻󠄢󠄳󠆂󠆔󠆁󠅹󠆓󠄬󠄺󠅊︄󠅫󠅈︋󠄝󠇁󠇚󠄑󠇐󠅔󠇂󠅿󠆳󠆺󠄥󠄆󠅲󠆥󠄇󠄡󠄣󠅍󠄽󠅞󠅻AI Model Outputs — Regurgitated (sometimes verbatim) in AI responses
  4. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅞󠄦󠄇󠅾󠅘︁󠄻󠄤󠆈󠄋󠆉󠆥󠄯󠇣󠅍󠄈󠅚󠅒󠄔󠄶󠆳󠅈󠇚󠅓󠄍󠆁󠇏󠆄󠄋󠆍󠅾󠅌󠄴󠇢󠄦︈󠆇󠆛󠆜︂AI-Powered Search — Summarized without attribution in AI search results

At each step, the connection between content and creator weakens. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇦󠆹󠇏󠆴󠆳󠅺󠄽󠇈󠆉󠆟︉󠆦󠅼󠇑󠅥󠄝󠆽󠆛󠄂󠅽󠇇󠅥󠆛󠇇󠄢󠄬︄󠆡󠄴󠅄︉󠅱󠅎󠄰󠄹󠆋󠇎󠄲󠄧󠄗By the time your article is training an AI model or appearing in an AI-generated summary, there's no technical way to prove it was ever yours.

󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆞󠇨󠅿󠆹󠅶󠇌󠄿󠇬󠆗󠆢󠆀󠆦󠅁󠇞󠄂󠆀󠅡󠅵󠅍󠇙󠆑󠅑󠅬󠄍󠇘󠆭󠇐︆󠅃︆󠅂󠆞󠇊󠄘󠆜󠅱󠅞󠇣󠆽󠅳Why Traditional Protection Fails

Copyright Notices Don't Travel

That © symbol at the bottom of your page? 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅥󠅹󠇋󠄅󠇌󠆦󠄹󠇃󠆙󠅝󠆻󠇐󠄮󠇁󠆅󠅹󠅊󠄽󠆿󠅩󠇝󠇀󠅚󠄮󠇟󠄾󠅦󠄴󠆺󠆔󠆽󠇈󠄙󠅲󠄒󠄏󠇎󠄮󠅊󠇂It doesn't follow your content through RSS feeds, API responses, or web scraping. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇉︅󠅿󠅃󠇅󠅺󠄼󠇁󠅲󠇨󠅏󠅸󠅠󠄰󠄍󠆡󠆯󠅡󠄏︄󠇁󠅱󠅻󠆣󠇆󠇟󠅐󠆫󠆔󠆍󠅄󠅞︂󠆆󠅧󠅰󠄬󠆉󠅶󠇟When your article appears on a licensee's site or in a training dataset, the copyright notice is typically stripped away.

Robots.txt Is Voluntary

The robots.txt file that tells crawlers to stay away is purely advisory. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇐󠄩︀󠄫󠇞󠄒󠄽󠇡󠅺󠄻󠄚󠅸󠄬󠆡︁󠆔󠅺󠇊󠇎󠅱󠄒󠅤󠇨󠄄󠅼󠆾󠇓󠇬󠄆󠄏󠆚󠇙󠇂󠆗󠆦󠆋󠅠󠄑󠅄󠄖Ethical crawlers respect it; many don't. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇌󠇒󠅕󠄄󠆅󠇏󠄻󠄛󠆟󠅤󠆠︇󠆮󠅃󠄞󠄱󠆲󠇔󠆿󠆬󠇜󠆛󠇍󠆒󠆠󠄹󠆭󠄌󠆅󠄁󠅰󠅞󠅿󠄒󠆂󠆦󠇞󠆐󠄍︎And even compliant crawlers may have already indexed your content before you added restrictions.

󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆽󠇬󠅦︅󠇪󠆇󠄳󠅤󠅲󠇮󠅔󠅐󠇑󠆩󠇓󠆸󠄎󠆒󠄡󠅊󠄨󠅟󠇭󠇯󠇗󠅃󠄒󠄻󠅭󠅆︄󠄳󠅅󠇐󠄄󠄑󠅼󠆆󠇂󠅘Paywalls Create Leakage

Paywalled content often leaks through:

  • Cached versions in search engines
  • Archive services
  • Social media screenshots
  • Authorized users sharing access
  • B2B licensees with different access controls

Metadata Gets Stripped

HTML metadata, author tags, and publication information are routinely removed when content is:

  • Copied and pasted
  • Reformatted for different platforms
  • Processed through content management systems
  • Scraped into datasets

󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢︎󠅥󠄸󠆕︋󠆤󠄶󠄙󠅴󠄭󠄴󠇌󠆓󠄱󠅰󠆻󠆡󠅎󠆻︈󠇚󠄑󠅱󠆃󠅉󠇥󠅕󠄐󠄂󠄱󠆳󠅆󠆝󠄇󠅫󠆼󠆼󠅙󠆍󠄑The Scale of the Problem

Consider the numbers:

  • Common Crawl contains over 250 billion web pages
  • The Pile (a popular AI training dataset) includes content from thousands of publishers
  • GPT-4 was reportedly trained on data from millions of websites
  • Google's AI Overview summarizes content from across the web without traditional click-through

For major publishers, this means:

  • Millions of articles distributed through B2B channels
  • Billions of page impressions on third-party platforms
  • Unknown quantities of content in AI training sets
  • Zero visibility into downstream usage

󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅑󠇑︅︀󠄇󠆋󠄿󠄽󠅵󠅉󠄹󠆿󠄂󠇛󠅖󠄵󠄰󠄲󠄽󠅆󠅝󠆁󠄂󠄚󠅷󠅶󠅹󠇀󠆌󠆹󠇀󠇠︋󠆺󠅇󠅚󠇕󠆲󠅷󠄗The "We Didn't Know" Defense

This distribution problem creates a legal vulnerability that AI companies have exploited: the innocent infringement defense. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅒󠄻󠇓󠅓󠄌󠆟󠄱󠇊󠆐󠅽󠅲󠅙󠄺󠄨󠆽󠇨󠇊󠆟󠄞󠄕󠆲󠅤󠅎󠅮󠆰󠅆󠆻︀󠄎󠆡󠇑󠅱󠆤󠆓󠇑󠇑󠇔︄󠆤󠄩When publishers sue AI companies for copyright infringement, the response is predictable:

"We scraped the open web. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆶󠅗󠆌󠇠󠄬󠅎󠄵󠄐󠆉︌󠅴󠇬󠆷︌︆󠆝󠆥󠆞󠆉󠇜󠇛󠅺󠇮󠄗󠆜󠄇󠆊︋󠆋󠆆󠄤󠆬󠄻󠆼󠅚󠇔󠄲󠅢󠆊󠆍We didn't know it was yours. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅤󠅻󠆮󠇙󠅬󠆁󠄾󠄿󠆍󠅠󠄓󠅦󠅽󠅦󠅇󠆜︎󠇊󠆠󠆊󠇛󠆑󠅫󠄳󠄴󠄺󠄻󠅤󠅒︆󠇈󠅢󠆝󠄸󠄝󠅄󠅼󠄩󠇙󠄿We can't control what users paste into our systems. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄦󠅸︋󠄮󠅂󠅵󠄳󠇪󠅶️󠆨󠇩︎󠇒︄󠅙󠇉󠆠󠆶󠄉︁󠆅󠇩󠅇󠆚︁︀󠆺󠅚󠄼󠆛󠅕󠄌󠄎󠇕󠆀󠆸󠄞︇󠄯There was no way to identify your content among billions of documents. "

󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢︊󠄞󠅖󠆁︄󠇨󠄿󠇥󠆗󠆡󠅴󠆉󠄡󠅋󠅐󠅢󠄤󠄜󠅠󠄳󠇆󠅃󠇁󠇮󠅕󠆽󠅰󠆒󠄄󠄱󠆋󠆊󠆖󠅅󠄧󠆦󠄜󠄙󠄒󠇜This defense has legal weight because it's technically true. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆳󠄃︆󠅿󠇪󠇓󠄿󠄓󠆈󠇩󠄤󠄩󠇡󠆩󠇀󠆮󠄜󠆝󠇮󠆩󠅖󠄏󠅰󠆓󠆽󠅣󠄝󠆑󠄏︀󠄢󠆐󠅭󠆔󠆵󠅙󠇤󠆟󠅃󠄨Without cryptographic proof of origin embedded in the content itself, publishers face an uphill battle proving:

  1. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇯󠆗󠆨󠇆︍󠆔󠄶󠄠󠆈󠅺󠇗󠅂󠆒󠇭󠅾󠄃󠇑󠅃󠄗︎󠅏󠇑󠇡󠆱󠆬󠇈󠅻󠇆󠇕󠆏󠅰󠆌󠅆󠄭󠄮󠆞󠇋󠄀️󠇩That specific content was theirs
  2. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅜󠄑󠅂󠇆︋󠅒󠄶︂󠅼󠆠︉︀󠄩️󠆍󠆣󠅡󠄩󠅩󠅒󠇢󠆟󠅂󠇜󠄺󠄃󠄌󠄅󠄶󠆽󠄬󠄑󠇦󠄅󠄫󠆘󠄜󠄞󠄸󠅵That the AI company knew (or should have known) 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅫󠅺󠄟󠆼󠆞󠇥󠄸󠆚󠆚󠅌󠆱󠆕󠄈󠅪󠆽󠄡󠆖󠄣󠄩󠆙󠇐󠆛󠆗󠄈󠆧󠅷󠆭󠆒󠆘󠆶󠆢󠆂󠅐󠅙󠆑󠄌󠄎󠆩󠄜︈it was copyrighted
  3. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄓󠆺󠅖󠆝󠆶󠆢󠄹󠅾󠆨󠇆󠅁󠅝󠇋󠆍󠅩󠆾󠅉󠆀󠅾󠅔󠆴󠄴󠅺󠆷󠄭︂󠅋󠅢󠄬󠅩󠄙󠅵󠅊︀︃󠆝︆󠅾󠇣󠆜That the content was used in training or outputs

The downstream distribution problem isn't just about losing attribution—it's about losing the ability to enforce your rights. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆺󠆆󠅲󠅺󠆲󠇮󠄼󠄌󠆢󠆅️󠅓󠆇︅󠅦︄󠄘󠇟󠄾󠄺󠄎󠆁󠄵󠇢󠅓󠅟󠆏󠅕󠆯󠄧󠇋󠄊󠇯󠆟󠄁󠅺󠇢󠆵󠄑︊## 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆕󠆃󠅜󠅹󠆛󠅋󠄱󠇟󠆃󠅇󠆾󠄸󠄎󠆤︆󠇁󠇫󠅼󠄟󠆙󠇪󠆥󠇁󠅊󠅁󠅓󠇤󠅛︃󠆹︁󠅩󠄱󠅼󠅔󠆴󠆻󠇘󠄻󠆍What's Different About Text

Images have had provenance solutions for years. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅳󠅑󠆽󠆩󠆖󠅧󠄿󠆎󠅺󠆃󠇅󠆺󠆣󠄻󠆫󠅯󠅭󠅜󠆚︈󠄫󠅷󠄓󠇊󠄀󠇒󠇥󠄅󠅧󠇁󠅸󠆱󠆮󠄵󠆏󠄕󠇒󠅲󠅈󠇎EXIF data, while imperfect, provides some attribution. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄲󠅌󠆜󠆌󠅒󠄿󠄶󠆎󠆦󠆢󠄅󠇛󠄭󠇀󠅄󠄠󠆃󠄾󠄡󠆆󠆌󠄯󠆄󠅻󠆃󠆪󠄣󠅋󠆳󠄇󠄍󠅡󠆖󠄀󠇊󠇏󠇫󠆾󠆗󠆦C2PA has enabled cryptographic provenance for images since 2021. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇨󠆡󠇫󠇣󠅥︈󠄻󠄼󠆉󠅫︊󠄈󠇣󠄡󠅃󠆅︈󠇁󠇅󠇙󠅾󠆈󠆄󠇪󠄐󠆯󠇂󠆎󠆙󠇞󠇦️󠅣󠄊󠅽󠇥󠄹󠆓󠇘󠄜But text has been the orphan of content authentication: | Content Type | Traditional Metadata | C2PA Support | |--------------|---------------------|--------------| | Images | EXIF, IPTC, XMP | Since 2021 | | Video | Container metadata | 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆍󠅊󠆁󠅩󠆿󠆠󠄺󠅸󠆖︂󠄴󠆅󠅶󠆤󠅫󠇁󠄸󠆷󠆴󠄷󠆯󠄾󠇫󠆴󠆾󠅼󠇄󠆎󠄞󠄶󠆎󠅣󠆤󠅜󠄿󠆉󠅤󠆩󠅽󠅮Since 2022 | | Audio | ID3 tags | Since 2022 | | PDF | Document properties | Since 2023 | | Plain Text | None | 2026 (C2PA 2.3) |

This gap matters because text is:

  • The majority of AI training data
  • The primary output of large language models
  • The format most easily copied and distributed
  • The hardest to track through distribution chains

󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄜󠇙󠄵󠄙󠅩󠇐󠄿󠆪󠆉󠄜󠅶󠆄󠆎󠆭󠄢󠅯󠅹󠅴󠄧󠄞󠆍󠄗󠅳󠆅󠅖︁󠆳󠇝︊󠄻󠅻󠆰󠄬󠇛󠄫󠅞󠇓󠅘󠄖󠇈The Solution: Provenance That Travels

The only way to solve the downstream distribution problem is to embed proof of origin into the content itself—not in surrounding metadata that gets stripped, not in a database that content gets separated from, but in the actual text. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆆󠆰󠅑󠅷󠇌󠆍󠄺󠇧󠆣󠆑󠆓󠄏󠆎󠅌󠅜󠅆󠆺󠇥︌󠄙󠆜󠆐󠆚󠄵󠄺󠆗󠄩󠅠󠇞󠇭󠅙󠄔󠇅󠅖󠅖󠄺󠅄󠆶󠇤󠇐This is what cryptographic text provenance enables:

Survives Copy-Paste

When someone copies your article and pastes it elsewhere, the embedded provenance travels with it. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆂󠇙󠄃󠇍󠇍󠅈󠄿󠄕󠅸󠅺󠇣󠄔󠇜︄󠇭󠆡󠄭󠅙󠅎󠅔󠇢󠅺󠅅󠆓󠇌󠄷󠄨󠄡󠆔󠄹󠆮󠅹󠅳󠆹󠄨󠅺󠅪󠆾󠇂󠄍The proof of origin is inseparable from the content. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅋󠄾󠅇󠇭󠆩󠆡󠄻󠆇󠅽︁󠅮󠅧󠆼󠆀󠄟󠆸󠇪󠇃󠄆󠄧󠆤󠄂󠅑󠇡󠅅󠄅󠄘󠆮︍󠄨󠅬󠇪󠅤󠆲󠆶󠆃󠅕󠇘󠆻󠆛### Survives B2B Distribution

As your content flows through wire services and licensees, the cryptographic signature remains intact. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅠󠄭󠇜󠅪󠅿󠇙󠄾󠆼󠆤󠄼︃󠅩󠅀󠄤󠇆󠅝󠆇󠄡󠆥󠇛󠆕󠆏󠆔󠄹󠆃󠅞󠅡󠄺󠆈󠅮󠆅󠆡︁󠅦󠇀󠅱󠄽︆󠆻󠇟Every downstream recipient can verify the original source.

Survives Scraping

When web crawlers collect your content for AI training, the provenance data is collected too. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄆󠆊󠅺󠆻󠄻󠅄󠄽󠅧󠆜󠇊󠆪󠅱󠄂󠆖󠆗󠆜󠅞󠄉󠄝︎󠆃󠇪󠇀󠇖󠇫󠆘󠄖󠄈︂󠇬︉󠇙󠄉󠅇󠆡󠆬󠆃󠆚󠅷󠆏The "we didn't know" defense becomes untenable when every piece of content carries cryptographic proof of ownership. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅹󠆴󠅎󠆷󠅱︎󠄾󠇃󠆔󠅕󠇄󠄐󠆢󠅥︇󠅊󠆁󠄮󠇀󠄌󠅃󠅹󠆯󠅛󠆍󠄙󠇃󠆿󠄉󠆨󠆤󠄋󠆨󠆢󠇨󠄎󠆡󠆋󠆓󠆷### Enables Formal Notice

Once content carries embedded provenance, publishers can formally notify AI companies: "Our content is marked. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆽󠄳󠄇󠆱󠇨󠆋󠄷󠅽󠅰󠆬︆︀󠄥󠄄󠇦️󠅑󠅆󠅊󠇛󠇃󠄡󠄛󠄳󠄽󠅪󠄗󠆔󠆮󠅣󠅱󠆶󠇧︊󠄍󠅡󠅆󠇖󠅪󠅪You can verify ownership via public API. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆇󠅟󠄿󠅐󠆧󠅫󠄽󠄈󠅽󠅎󠇘󠆑󠄤󠄂󠆛󠅼󠄐󠆰︋︅󠄹󠅈󠄈󠆘󠄕󠅧󠅝󠅝󠅿󠆉󠆄󠄾󠄖󠆺󠅯︅󠄱󠄡󠇡󠄃Continued unauthorized use is now willful, not innocent. "

󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅤󠄢︋󠆢󠆊󠇐󠄸󠇗󠆁󠇈︂󠆔︍󠇊󠆺󠅘󠅯󠅛󠅪󠅓󠆣󠆫󠄯󠄢󠇢󠄮󠄗󠅠󠆿︍󠅧󠇆󠅘︉󠆄󠄅󠇐󠅽󠇂󠄏## The Transformation

The downstream distribution problem has persisted because there was no technical solution. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅗󠆋󠆢︌󠄟󠄇󠄱󠆿󠆦󠆢󠆇󠄍󠆽󠇪󠄆󠅍󠄻󠇛󠇊󠄃󠇅󠅉󠆼󠅗󠄫󠇚󠄁󠄞󠆏󠄐󠇡󠅉󠇛󠅮󠄎󠅡󠄩󠆶󠄈󠆜Content flowed freely while attribution evaporated. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄳󠆘󠄍󠅕󠆻󠆋󠄵󠆰󠆮󠆡󠇁󠇛󠆛󠇦󠇊󠅻︆󠆂󠇨󠄳󠄧󠆒󠅕󠄤󠆣󠅞󠇅󠅞󠅃󠇌󠇂󠄐󠄿󠄉󠆅󠇘󠅔󠄰󠇞󠅞That's changing. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄖󠆧󠇞󠄺󠇢󠄜󠄸󠅈󠅴󠆬󠇄󠅹󠆓󠆂󠅏󠇎󠇑󠄵󠆩󠅎󠇥󠇬󠄖󠄬󠅿󠆁󠄫󠅳󠄸󠆬󠆱󠅽󠄁󠇒󠇖󠄲󠄉󠇝󠅄󠆇With cryptographic text provenance:

Before:

  • Content published → distributed → scraped → attribution lost
  • Publisher: "You used our content"
  • AI Company: "Prove it. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅅󠄍󠇃󠆡󠇆󠆿󠄰󠅺󠆙󠅸󠇝󠅾󠆣󠆪󠅟󠅾︋󠅔󠆊󠄂󠇜󠆯󠆏󠄣󠅭󠅅󠇪󠄚󠅺️󠄾󠅋󠄅󠆚󠆽󠆈󠇡󠅾󠆜󠄊We didn't know. "

󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆬󠄐󠇍󠅹󠅊󠇯󠄸󠅔󠆣󠄦󠆨󠅊󠆭󠅆󠆨󠅣󠇊󠅱󠅕󠅚󠆽󠅅󠄰󠄔󠄍󠄙󠆹󠅓󠇔󠆽󠄋󠆪󠇟󠆟󠆵󠇂󠄳󠇘󠇄󠆀After:

  • Content published with embedded provenance → distributed → scraped → provenance intact
  • Publisher: "You used our content. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆂󠆝󠄴󠆪󠅬󠆂󠄷󠇝󠆎󠅲󠇌󠆂︂󠄙󠅖︋︊︂󠄤󠅘󠅜󠄔󠇐︉󠇍󠅀󠅗󠅕󠄵󠄈󠄰󠅈󠅘︌󠆝󠇤󠆪󠅉󠅶󠇦Here's the cryptographic proof. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅪󠄦󠆏󠆦󠅈󠅷󠄹󠅴󠆫󠆟󠇖󠅝󠄘󠅝󠆻󠆼󠅙󠅦󠅉󠅆󠄥󠇤󠆑󠄢󠄽󠆖󠅝󠄟󠆣󠄩󠅺󠆁󠇎󠆜󠄉󠇒󠆭︇󠄹󠆚We notified you it was marked. " 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅤󠇙󠆛󠄕󠇮󠇂󠄹󠅬󠆍󠅈󠄆󠇥󠆄󠄰󠆓󠆔󠄍󠅫︋󠆔󠅫󠆅󠄱󠆗󠆧󠇌󠄭󠅹󠇤󠆉󠇟󠄨󠇢󠅘󠄜󠆁󠅠󠇨󠅦󠅲- AI Company: [No viable defense]

󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄥󠅋︈󠅥󠅼󠆄󠄽︀󠅳󠇙󠄦󠄇󠄀󠅯󠅬󠅶󠆧󠆐󠄉󠇏󠇩󠅺󠇣󠅁󠆆󠇯󠆑󠄞󠄄󠇙󠅕󠆶󠄁󠄬󠅩󠅤󠄫󠇆󠆬󠅁What Publishers Should Do Now

1. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇣󠇈󠆽󠅃󠇥󠄼󠄻︍󠆒󠆕󠄪󠇪󠅖󠅜︆󠅽󠄅󠅕󠅷󠆕󠇄󠇊󠄕󠅈󠆩󠆼󠆅󠅐︎󠆄󠅴︆󠄎󠅲󠇅󠆬󠇒󠅱󠄑︂Audit Your Distribution Chain

Map every path your content takes after publication:

  • Direct syndication partners
  • Wire service relationships
  • Aggregator appearances
  • Social platform distribution
  • Known scraping activity

2. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅺󠆎󠅑󠇫󠄰󠅡󠄶󠇍󠆨󠄀󠇍󠆴󠅓󠇝󠆥󠅜󠆋󠇢󠆡󠅴󠅺󠅖󠄺󠇪󠄺︁󠆞󠄘󠄺󠇆󠅚󠄕󠄟󠆇󠄁︂󠅵󠆏󠆼󠆑Understand Your Exposure

Estimate how much of your content exists in AI training datasets. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆭󠄏󠆚󠄈󠅕󠆽󠄰󠄳󠅻󠄫󠄤󠅸󠅇󠅍󠆋󠅽󠆐󠆻󠆚󠆶󠆨󠄫󠄞󠄺󠆅󠄰󠆶󠇡󠄞󠇏󠆆󠄲󠆺󠅰󠄄󠅗󠅹󠅍󠅭󠄌Tools like Have I Been Trained can help for images; text is harder to audit but equally important. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇘󠇂󠆥󠇧󠆧󠆳󠄷󠆩󠆬󠅟󠇣󠇑󠄘󠄨󠄹󠆱󠆜󠆦󠆪︀󠄷󠆨󠆠󠅗󠄀󠇪󠇀󠆐󠆯󠅆󠄂󠅌󠅃󠆵󠅊󠅋󠇇󠅃󠇛󠇖### 3. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅈󠇑󠇍󠄳󠄒󠄞󠄲󠆜󠆌󠇣󠅾︂󠇔󠄄󠆃󠇧󠆺︀󠆝󠆮󠇎󠅂󠇞󠇍󠅭󠄢󠆀󠄞󠄑󠅱󠆞󠆬󠄎󠅲󠇃󠅾󠆨︇︍󠇔Implement Provenance Infrastructure

As text provenance standards mature, early adopters will have advantages:

  • Retroactive proof of publication dates
  • Established verification infrastructure
  • Formal notice capabilities
  • Licensing leverage

4. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄲󠆕󠄠󠆺󠅞󠅅󠄹󠄺󠆉󠇨󠅡󠆰󠆋󠇁󠇩󠄴󠆤󠆚󠄼󠄡󠅤󠅊󠆅󠄆󠅰󠅧󠅡󠄒󠄬󠄼󠅭󠅲󠅤󠇎󠄃󠇂󠆌󠅫󠅻󠇐Prepare for Licensing Conversations

The downstream distribution problem is also a licensing opportunity. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅭󠆰󠄐󠆋󠇜󠇭󠄽󠅂󠅽󠇐󠄁󠆾󠆫󠄌󠄷󠄪󠄛󠄨󠅌󠆳󠅗︋󠆩󠅁󠅠󠄕︊󠄼󠅫󠅮󠆆󠅎󠄁󠆱󠇆󠅞󠆎󠇒󠄲󠇐AI companies need quality training data. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇮󠇊︆󠄲󠅴󠆉󠄲󠇕󠆭󠄥󠄽󠅖󠆝󠅚󠇄󠄀󠄃󠇛󠄡󠆦󠅙󠄴󠇥󠇅󠅹󠅆󠅻󠆾󠆱󠇍󠇮󠆲󠆯󠄶󠇫󠄞󠅊󠄚󠄬󠇂Publishers have it. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄜󠄥󠄣󠄿󠇑󠅮󠄰󠆲󠆣󠆙󠆅󠆽󠄛󠅪󠆎󠅥󠄰󠅼󠅬󠄘󠆉󠇊󠆀󠇉󠆩󠄬󠄉󠆌󠅡󠄞󠅌󠆆󠆹󠆝󠄆󠆓󠄤󠇫󠄄󠅽Provenance infrastructure enables the licensing frameworks that turn unauthorized use into revenue. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅨󠄵󠆎︁󠆼󠇅󠄹󠆱󠆠󠇜︄󠇈󠆍󠆜󠇝󠇬󠅖󠆣󠄦󠇏󠄥󠄶︎󠄏󠇫󠆫󠄧󠅥󠄌󠇠󠆜󠇛󠇐󠆦󠆽󠆺󠄕󠇜󠅖󠆊---

󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄂󠅹󠇫󠄁󠅭󠅱󠄿󠅙󠅾︎󠅒󠆹󠄃󠇇󠇆󠄣󠆁󠅎󠇤󠄩󠄅󠄀󠅑󠆠󠇯︊󠅔󠅦󠆲󠇃󠇣󠅞󠇫︋󠅼󠆻󠄭󠇄󠇋󠆉The Path Forward

The downstream distribution problem isn't going away—content will continue to flow through complex ecosystems. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆖󠆻󠆗󠄋󠅀󠆲󠄽󠆈󠅵󠇨󠆒󠅙︈󠇠󠄞󠆫󠆮󠅻󠆢󠆹︎󠄊󠆜󠆛︎󠆞󠅮󠅛󠄱󠅀︀󠆤󠄥󠆼󠆀󠅝󠅐󠅲󠄵󠆓But the attribution problem can be solved. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄞︈󠅸󠆅󠆯󠅜󠄳󠆯󠅶󠆖󠇨󠄙󠄊󠅀󠅙󠆲󠇡󠄔󠆼󠇩󠇧󠇝󠇔󠆛󠅴󠇯󠅰󠇊️󠄂󠆳󠄦󠅗󠇅󠇔󠆠󠆦︌󠆁󠆥Cryptographic provenance that travels with content transforms the equation. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠄀󠅉︌󠅳󠄍󠄓󠄴󠆪󠆦󠆼󠅩󠆁󠅲󠅖󠇋󠆋󠇥󠄊󠇓󠇁︇󠆅︆󠄐󠅲󠆩󠅒󠇡󠄓󠇩󠅵󠄞󠅠󠇉󠆙󠆫󠄂󠆴󠄒󠆿Publishers gain proof of ownership that survives any distribution path. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅡󠆷󠇫󠄄󠄗󠅋󠄺󠆇󠆨󠅤󠆸󠇚󠄐󠇐󠅄󠄂󠆔󠄐󠇦󠆷󠆅󠅃󠅨󠇬󠄂󠇓󠅗󠇝󠇖󠄀󠄣󠇫󠆷󠆏󠇈󠇍󠄸󠆏󠆖︎AI companies lose the "we didn't know" defense. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇇󠅗󠄊󠇑󠄟󠇭󠄴󠅃󠅷󠆇︇󠄷󠆦󠅨󠅒󠆳󠅄󠇊︉󠄡󠄄󠆌󠅻󠆬󠅗󠆀󠄜󠆽󠇫󠆓󠆡󠇤󠆪󠅃󠄽󠇞󠅧󠆇󠆀󠅹And the foundation is laid for sustainable content licensing in the AI era. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠆚︎󠅞󠇀󠇍󠆏󠄸󠆐󠅴󠆌󠄀󠅉󠄺󠆛󠇛︅󠆢󠆓︎󠇣󠄚󠇮󠇃󠇈︁󠄪󠆧󠅿󠇣󠅻󠅻󠇄︆󠅋󠅁󠄠󠄴󠄾󠅗󠆘The question isn't whether to implement text provenance—it's how quickly you can get there before your competitors. 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇥󠄧󠅴󠆲󠆶󠄙󠄵󠇘󠆁󠅨󠇩󠆍󠇔󠄞󠄠󠄡󠄥󠄺󠇖󠅸󠆐󠅩󠄓︅󠄣󠅵󠆹󠄠󠆷󠄧󠆨󠆔󠇒󠆠󠅕󠄸󠇓󠅲󠄹󠆊Learn more about text provenance infrastructure: 󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠇈󠇌󠆆︋󠇋󠆿󠄴󠅴󠆈󠇝󠄥󠄫󠆠󠆈󠆮󠄚󠇏󠆜󠆰󠆗󠄉󠇃󠄣󠆢󠇟󠇄󠄮󠄽󠇊︁󠄜󠆩︆󠄣󠅰󠅱󠆊󠇙󠅦󠇒encypherai.com/publisher-demo

#ContentProvenance #Publishing #Copyright #AITraining #ContentProtection󠇟󠇠󠇡󠇢󠅡󠆿︃󠄼󠄨︅󠄿󠅀󠆕󠆆󠆛󠇓󠄂󠅊󠄐󠄔󠆬󠄫󠇏󠇉󠆙󠄍󠆱󠆯󠆺󠄣󠆂󠆤󠄮󠅭󠆬󠆜󠄷󠄥󠇃󠅒󠅜󠄚󠄔󠅲

Topics

#ContentProvenance#Publishing#Copyright#AITraining#ContentProtection
Back to all posts

Enjoyed this article? Share it!